Trophy-dilemmas with the Legendary Edition for the Ps5

Hiya!

Wanted to relive the trilogy recently and started my ME1 save from 4 years ago. I then restarted the game with a new save since.. 4 years is some time ago as well. Playing the Legendary Edition here on my ps5.

And I’m big on trophies these days. Anyways, so not 10 minutes in I get this trophy right.. 250 kills for the entire trilogy set of trophy list, and I’m like - yeah okey dokey here we go. But that seems to have erased my trophy list for the entire ME1 set of trophies. Now only ME2, 3 and the Legendary Edition set of trophies are showing.

So I go offline to check on them locally. There they are, so I start again in offline mode, but I’m not convinced the trophies are popping like they should. I got to the point in Presidium where you wanna have a shakedown with Fist, and the two guys pin you down with guns and you have a charm Option and an intimidation option. Should have popped the “Charismatic” trophy, but it didn’t. What’s wrong here..? Can I do something to resolve the matter? When I go back online the trophies are still not showing.

Anyways thanks. If you’d help me out here it’d be such a joy. Fantastic series, I’m just too much into the trophies to not be bothered by it at this point.