How do you guys usually handle this???

I am coaching at Texas Southern to start my Closed career legacy. We finished the first season 22-10 which was a serious blessing. But here's my issue I have a senior PG from the year before that was the teams 3rd. Leading scorer at 12 ppg. But he's a 62 overall. I have a incoming freshman coming in that's a 67 overall from California so I think you see my situation here. I'm wondering who would you all start to avoid the player getting unhappy he's not playing as much... I figured I'd let the original PG start to finish his senior year on a high note. Thanks in advance.