Lillia or Evelyn as otp

Hi, I’m looking for opinions. Between Lillia and Evelyn, which of the two is a more reliable carry?

I’ve played both to a good understanding, but I feel both are unreliable… but I guess I like them enough and looking for who is better to add to my pool?

Lillia is a scaler, sometimes games are decided early (if I’m given the chance, I carry late game). Eve is countered by hard cc and hard to play from behind.

Any thoughts? Diamond elo but this is mostly for norm games. Thanks :)