"Best" NYC style slice...

My GF is from NYC area, and Buffalo pizza isn't her thing (it hurts me too...). We have started to try and find a decent NYC style pizza for her (to no avail). I'll be honest, we haven't searched too hard yet. She has been to "Brooklyn's finest" in depew / west seneca, and says it is okay. We had Gino's on Elmwood, and she was appalled. I believe there are 1 or 2 spots on Sheridan in Tonawonda that we are meaning to check out. Anyway, please help.

P.S. - Cluck Cluck Moo Moo for a burger was an unforgivable experience.

Thanks, your neighbor.